This is a comment by Craig Boot on my previous post. I think it deserves a reply:
Craig's comment:
"An excellent book, perhaps the finest I have
ever read, on this subject is, 'How Long O Lord?' by D.A. Carson. It
is not written in academese, but it is scholarly and readable. Carson
demonstrates that God's absolute sovereingty and man's absolute
responsibility are co-present as co-truths in the Scriptures; how this
can be so is a mystery beyond mankind to grasp. Therefore, we just
accept both truths."
Reply: The answer is easy. Man's responsibility
and God's sovereignty is not at odds because man's responsibility has
nothing to do with free will. Man is responsible because as a creature, he is
answerable to his creator, and his creator requires perfect obedience. Whether man can keep the commandments or not is
irrelevant. Moral responsibility is therefore grounded in God's
sovereignty and not man's free will (man has no free will). And it is
precisely because God is sovereign, that man is responsible for
breaking the commandments. God's Sovereignty and man's responsibility
must go together. If God is not sovereign, it follows that man is not
responsible. Therefore, God's sovereignty and man's
responsibility is not an unknowable mystery as claimed by D A Carson,
but a clear logical necessity, flowing from the very nature of God Himself.
As I wrote on the 24th of July... a quotation from Vincent Cheung.
"If it is true that moral responsibility presupposes moral ability, and Paul states that the sinner lacks this ability, then it follows that no sinner is responsible for his sins. That is, if a sinner is only a sinner if he has the ability to obey but refuses to obey, since Paul says that the sinner indeed lacks the ability to obey, then it follows that a sinner is not a sinner. ... "The Bible teaches that the non-Christian is a sinner, and at the same time teaches that he lacks the ability to obey God. This means that man is morally responsible even if he lacks moral ability; that is, man must obey God even if he cannot obey God. It is sinful for a person to disobey God whether or not he has the ability to do otherwise. Thus ... moral responsibility is not grounded on moral ability or on free will; rather, moral responsibility is grounded on God's sovereignty – man must obey God's commands because God says that man must obey, and whether or not he has the ability to obey is irrelevant. " V. Cheung - Problem of Evil p5-6"
Chatboard (0)